Spring Law Spring Law Spring Law Spring Law
  • Home
  • About
    • Our Approach
    • Our People
    • Our Case List
  • Services
    • Dispute Avoidance
    • General Counsel Advisory Services
    • Risk & Litigation Ready Audit
    • Merger & Acquisition Risk Profiling
    • Rep Control
    • Dispute Resolution
    • Business Disputes
    • Personal Disputes
    • Investigations
    • Intelligence
    • Spring Law | Chichester
  • Insights
  • SRA
    • Pricing Policy
    • Complaints Handling Procedure
  • Contact
Spring Law Spring Law
  • Home
  • About
    • Our Approach
    • Our People
    • Our Case List
  • Services
    • Dispute Avoidance
    • General Counsel Advisory Services
    • Risk & Litigation Ready Audit
    • Merger & Acquisition Risk Profiling
    • Rep Control
    • Dispute Resolution
    • Business Disputes
    • Personal Disputes
    • Investigations
    • Intelligence
    • Spring Law | Chichester
  • Insights
  • SRA
    • Pricing Policy
    • Complaints Handling Procedure
  • Contact
Feb 22
Dripping tap needing plumbing

Key gig economy case reaches Supreme Court

  • 22 February 2018

A plumber’s legal battle for working rights will be closely watched by “gig economy” workers when it reaches the Supreme Court on Tuesday.

Gary Smith, who worked for Pimlico Plumbers for six years, began his fight when he wanted to reduce his hours following a heart attack.

Lower courts have ruled that he is entitled to basic workers’ rights, although technically self-employed. These rights include the national minimum wage and paid holiday.

Mr Smith won his most recent victory in the Court of Appeal a year ago, but Pimlico Plumbers and its founder, Charlie Mullins, are appealing against that decision, in a hearing expected to last two days.

The case hinges on the distinction between Mr Smith’s status as either a self-employed contractor, or a worker for the company.

He was VAT-registered and paying tax on a self-employed basis, but worked solely for Pimlico Plumbers. After he suffered a heart attack in 2010, Mr Smith, from Kent, wanted to work three days a week rather than five.

Pimlico refused his request and took away his branded van, which he had hired. He claims he was dismissed. An employment tribunal found that the plumbers were workers, but not employees. The Court of Appeal backed that decision.

Employment status

Jason Moyer-Lee, general secretary of the Independent Workers Union of Great Britain, said the rise of the “gig economy” made the issue of employment status more important than ever.

“Tribunals’ and courts’ interpretations of these issues have done quite well to keep up with the times – that’s why nearly all high-profile ‘gig economy’ cases have declared the individual to be a worker, and consequently entitled to minimum wage rights and holiday pay,” he said.

“I expect the Supreme Court will do the same with the Pimlico Plumbers case.”

Mr Mullins, the founder of London-based Pimlico Plumbers, says that plumbers were hired on the basis that they were self-employed, provided their own materials and did not have workers’ benefits, but were paid significantly more as a result.

He argues that the case has nothing to do with the gig economy and that Mr Smith is not in the same as an Uber driver.

“There is no comparison between a skilled tradesperson, like a plumber earning £150,000 a year, and a bike courier or minicab driver, struggling to make minimum wage,” Mr Mullins said.

“This is the distinction that we are hoping to make clear to the Supreme Court.”

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Reddit
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
  • E-Mail

Comments are closed.

Recent Posts

  • Reforms Under the Employment Rights Bill 2024   3 June 2025
  • Spring Law in the UK Supreme Court 12 May 2025
  • A New Approach to Costs in the Business and Property Courts 12 May 2025
  • Employers beware of discrimination! Tribunal awards £1.1m in damages to employee for disability discrimination 16 November 2023
  • Push payment fraud and the ‘Quincecare’ duty: court rules in favour of customers 6 May 2022
LinkedIn icon
Cyber Essentials certification mark
The Lawyer Network member logo

London | Chichester | Gibraltar

Pricing Complaints Legal Privacy Cookies

©2025 Spring Law | Registered Company No. 5512395 | Website by Maroon Balloon & StudioMoo

We use cookies to improve your experience on our website. For information on cookies and how we use them, please see our Cookie Policy